
Today we head home after having spent a delicious week in our Maine cottage with our sons Darien and Toby, along with our daughter-in-law Betsy and Toby’s girlfriend Candice. We immersed ourselves in memory and tradition while we were here. Portraits of my great-great grandparents John and Remember Berry Swett, are on the wall, as are the portraits of their daughter Sarah Berry Swett, who married Albion Ricker. Sarah Ricker married Thomas Bates and they gave birth to my grandfather Albert who married Eleanor Fulcher, and they in turn gave birth to my father and two uncles. There are also large group shots of family reunions, including the eleven first cousins and their 18 children (most no longer children). The cottage, built by my great grandmother Sarah Ricker, stands atop Ricker Hill Orchards, which is still an active apple farm run by the Rickers, my third cousins.
When we come to Maine there are certain rituals that we follow. One is a hike up Streaked Mountain to pick blueberries. Another is a five-hour hike up and down Tumbledown Mountain, complete with hiking sticks carved by my grandfather and uncles (one of them over a hundred years old). The latter hike, strenuous but satisfying, is what I want to focus on today. It is special because, in addition to spectacular vistas, it has a pristine lake on top in which we sometimes swim. Only those who hike up Tumbledown can enjoy it as there is no road. The route we take, the Loop Trail, involves at one point clambering up four metal rungs set in the rock, shimmying through a crevice, and then crossing over a peak that looks down upon the lake, which mirrors the surrounding peaks. It is as though we have been presented with a shining emerald for our labors.
Thinking about the moment that way brings to mind a passage from a Vladimir Nabokov short story. “Cloud, Castle, Lake” (you can read it here) is, for the most part, a 1941 Kafkaesque allegory about a man forced to go on a “pleasure trip” and bullied into having “fun” with the rest of the passengers rather than follow his own private reveries. And yet, in the midst of the trip, he comes across a moment of startling beauty that promises to redeem his life. Here’s the passage I remember:
Upstairs was a room for travelers. ‘You know, I shall take it for the rest of my life,’ Vasili Ivanovich is reported to have said as soon as he had entered it. The room itself had nothing remarkable about it. On the contrary, it was a most ordinary room, with a red floor, daisies daubed on the white walls, and a small mirror half filled with the yellow infusion of the reflected flowers – but from the window one could clearly see the lake with its cloud and its castle, in a motionless and perfect correlation of happiness. Without reasoning, without considering, only entirely surrendering to an attraction the truth of which consisted in its own strength, a strength which he had never experienced before, Vasili Ivanovich in one radiant second realized that here in this little room with that view, beautiful to the verge of tears, life would at last be what he had always wished it to be. What exactly it would be like, what would take place here, that of course he did not know, but all around him were help, promise, and consolation – so that there could not be any doubt that he must live here. In a moment he figured out how he would manage it so as not to have to return to Berlin again, how to get the few possessions that he had – books, the blue suit, her photograph. How simple it was turning out!
Of course he is not allowed to stay but is hustled off. It is up to the reader to determine whether the villains of the piece are Stalinist communism, Hitlerian fascism, American consumer capitalism or some other “ism.” But in that magical moment, everything comes together.
The lake atop Tumbledown offers me a momentary glimpse into some other reality, some other life.
3 Comments
Celtic spirituality uses the term “thin places” to describe places (and even times) when heaven and earth seem so close, they intermingle. Dr. Tisdale of Yale Divinity School says it this way: “For in thin places, boundaries of time and space fade away. There is no yesterday, today or tomorrow–only eternity stretching forth in a timeless continuum.”
Both Tumbledown Mountain and the room described in “Cloud, Castle, Lake” seem to be thin places - moments of “perfect being” as you mention, Robin. It is interesting to reflect whether the Platonic “trinity” of the true, the good and the beautiful is also evidenced here, and whether this combination might be a way of noticing those thin places. The true “which consists of its own strenth”, the good of “help, promise and consolation” and the beautiful which brings a “motionless and perfect correlation of happines.”
Safe travels. Thanks for the lovely passage.
Blakde, I accidentally deleted your comment as I was weeding spam from the website. Darn! Do you mind sending it again? But send it to me by e-mail because I’ve had to close down the comments section because this particular post is getting attacked by medication ads. You mentioned, I believe, an E. M. Forster story.
My e-mail, as you know, is rrbates[at]smcm[dot]edu.
This notion of “thin places,” Susan, is very powerful and I’ve never encountered it before. Is it like Marcel Eliade’s concept of sacred (as opposed to profane) space? Or Virginia Woolf’s moments of being? And where is this Platonic trinity described? In The Republic? I want to dive into it more.
Sent: Saturday, July 31, 2010 2:51 PM
To: Bates, Robin R
Subject: Tumbledown
Dear Robin,
In my comments on your Tumbledown / Nabokov column, I began by exclaiming that you are a man after my own heart! Beyond that, I’m not sure what I said, although I must have thanked you for sharing the excellent Nabokov story. I loved the story and your comments on it. I’m an incurable Romantic, and I love hiking. My nickname, Blade Lawless, was my trail name when I hiked all of the Appalachian Trail in 2000–maybe the best 6-month period of my life. The Nabokov story brings to mind so many great works of Romantic lit that I wouldn’t know where to begin making comparisons. One work does occur to me as being perhaps particularly similar, and that is the Forster short story, “The Road from Colonus.” Do you know it?
Keep up the good work on the blog, although I don’t know how you have time for it if you’re teaching too. I love your mingling of sports and literary topics, although your subject of today, NBA basketball, leaves me cold when I’m not downright disgusted by the vulgar, ridiculous behavior of many of its practitioners (I hope I don’t sound priggish. Surely I’m not the only one who gets sick of all the screaming and chest pounding?). Soccer I would characterize, with apologies to Mark Twain, as a “a good run spoiled,” but I love tennis, golf, college basketball (I live in North Carolina!), and all endurance and adventure sports. Cycling, along with hiking, works especially well for me to cleanse the doors of perception.
Best regards,
Blade
From: Bates, Robin R
Sent: Saturday, July 31, 2010 3:04 PM
To: Tim Lovelace
Subject: RE: Tumbledown
I’m so glad you wrote back, Blade, because I felt bad about deleting your comment. Every once in a while a post gets swarmed by spam and I was trying to go through it fast and hit you by accident.
I am very, very impressed that you hiked the Appalachian Trail! “Blade Lawless” takes on a whole new significance when I hear that. It’s as though you step outside normal time and social convention (lawlessly but focused as a blade) in an endeavor like that. If you are ever interested in writing about how your love and knowledge of literature entered into that experience (as I’m sure they must have), I’d love to run it on for a “Sports Saturday” column.
Incidentally, your comment on NBA basketball is dead on and leaves me feeling a little sheepish. Here I am talking about James as a team player right after he gets ESPN to devote an entire hour to his decision! I guess I set the bar rather low. And you don’t sound priggish at all.
I don’t know the Forster story but will track it down. And I’ll also go and close down the comments section on the Nabokov blog, given that I now have received 100 spam messages or so on it. “And thick and fast they came at last and more and more and more,” I find myself thinking in a passage from a poem that I bet you know.
It’s always a joy to hear from you. Best, Robin
From: Tim Lovelace [haystoun@yahoo.com]
One Trackback
[...] short story “The Road from Colonus,” which reader Blade Lawless had recommended after reading my post on Nabokov’s “Cloud Castle Lake” (which I did in fact find [...]